Dual Purpose: Diagnosis and Treatment
The overall management of atypia and early cancer is similar, each
requiring the precise removal of all or part of the involved vocal fold
tissue for microscopic examination [excisional biopsy].
Often the entire lesion is removed during excisional biopsy. If the
entire lesion is removed – with an edge of normal tissue surrounding
the abnormal tissue – no further treatment (chemotherapy or radiation
therapy) is necessary.
Key Information
Voice Preservation and Cancer Treatment Possible
Unlike
cancers in most other parts of the body, early vocal fold cancers do
not always require removal of a significant amount of normal tissue
when surgically treating lesions. Excision of the early cancer and
preservation of normal tissue result in better voice outcomes.
90 to 95 Percent Cure Rate for Early-Stage Cancer
Early diagnosis and complete excision result in excellent cure rates.
Microscopic Analysis of Cellular Features – Histopathological Analysis
After excision of a lesion, a microscopic analysis of the lesion's cell features will be performed to determine:
- Whether or not the lesion is cancerous
- Whether or not the resection successfully removed the entire lesion along with a non-cancerous surrounding margin
Perspective on Surgical and Radiation Therapy for Early Cancer
- General rule for surgical excision: As a general rule, any vocal fold lesion that has not penetrated through the basement membrane of the vocal fold epithelium is treated via surgical excision. By definition, atypia never invades lower than this point, although cancer may.
- Normal vocal fold "untouched" in surgical excision: Surgical excision may result in a better vocal outcome than radiation
therapy (XRT) because the normal vocal fold is not touched in surgical
excision, while both vocal folds are affected in radiation therapy.
- Radiation therapy is single-use: Use of radiation therapy in the treatment of early cancer may be
undesirable, since XRT is a single-use cancer treatment and would be
considered unnecessary for minimal microscopic disease. The excisional
biopsy that is necessary to establish the diagnosis may be adequate
treatment for a small lesion.
Key Information
- Treatment for vocal fold early cancer must be individualized.
- Decisions
regarding the use of radiation therapy or surgery will depend upon the
nature of the lesion (size, depth, location), a patient's vocal needs,
the experience of the surgeon and radiation therapist, and other
pertinent medical factors.
What are the complications of treatment for vocal fold atypia/cancer?
Both radiation therapy and phonomicrosurgical excision can cause a
number of complications. Patients should discuss treatment and possible
complications of treatment with their physician.
In Brief: Complications Associated with Phonomicrosurgery
| Complication |
What Happens |
Why It Occurs |
Treatment |
Hemorrhage |
Bleeding; coughing up blood |
Re-bleeding after surgery |
If uncontrolled, need for surgical intervention |
Airway obstruction |
Blocked airway causing breathing difficulties |
Can result from swelling, although rare |
- Establish temporary airway
- Remove excess tissue causing the blocked airway
|
Granuloma formation (For more information, see Vocal Fold Granuloma) |
Inflammation-response growths on vocal folds over irritated areas |
Usually occurs with reflux |
- Anti-reflux therapy
- Voice rest
- Surgical excision when necessary
|
Vocal fold scarring |
Scar tissue formation in vocal folds |
Scar-response to surgical excision |
No definitive treatment at present |
Excess hoarseness and dysphonia |
Voice symptoms greater than expected after surgery |
Lack of breath support, aerodynamic inefficiency |
- Voice therapy
- Medialization procedures
|
In Brief: Complications Associated With Radiation Therapy (XRT)
Radiation therapy can cause side effects and complications that
affect voice outcomes. The area affected by XRT side effects or
complications is larger than that affected by phonomicrosurgery because
XRT treatment affects a broader area and does not distinguish between
normal and cancerous cells. Current efforts increasingly try to target
XRT to the cancerous lesion.
| Complication |
What Happens |
Why It Occurs |
Treatment |
Fibrosis of the normal vocal fold epithelium |
Fibrous tissue formation, resulting in loss of vocal fold pliability |
Radiation therapy does not distinguish between normal and cancerous areas; also results from injury and inflammation |
If reflux present, anti-reflux treatment |
Vocal fold dryness (laryngitis sicca), which produces hoarseness |
Dry mucous membranes, decreasing ability of vocal folds to vibrate |
Destruction of mucous glands from radiation, which affects both cancer cells and normal cells |
No reliable, definitive treatment at present |
In Brief: Serious Complications Associated with Radiation Therapy (XRT)
| Rare |
Very Rare |
|
Note: Both complications can drastically limit vocal fold function, impairing voice |
Additional primary cancers over a period of years |
Peri-Operative Care
- Anti-reflux therapy: After surgery, treatment for backflow of stomach fluids to the voice box area (laryngopharyngeal reflux)
will be provided, since reflux frequently occurs post-surgery. The
exposure of "raw" surgical wounds within the larynx to acidic stomach
fluids that have backflowed to the area could significantly hamper
healing and recovery and increase risk for complications. (For more information, see Reflux Laryngitis.)
- Antibiotics: As with most surgical procedures, preventive antibiotic treatment may
be provided to minimize the risk of post-surgical infections.
- Analgesics: Reduction of pain after surgery helps recovery to proceed as quickly and painlessly as possible.
- Voice rest: Complete voice rest is usually advised for about two weeks, with
modified voice use advised for two additional weeks, in order to
optimize healing and the recovery of voice function.
- Voice therapy: Often, both preoperative and postoperative voice therapy are
recommended to help patients recuperate from surgery and rehabilitate
voice after surgery. (For more information, see Voice Therapy.)
Red Flag
Atypia Frequently Recurs
- Although
removal of atypia typically precludes the later development of cancer,
atypical epithelium frequently recurs and requires repeat endoscopic
excisions.
- New phonosurgical developments in resection
and reconstruction have facilitated improved voice outcomes despite
repeated surgical removal of atypia.
Vocal Fold Reconstruction After Phonosurgical Management
Once the voice box has healed from removal of the lesion, vocal fold
reconstruction can be done if/when necessary. Vocal fold reconstruction
may involve medialization to help bring the vocal edge(s) to the
middle, resulting in better glottic closure and allowing vocal fold
vibration during sound production.
Monitoring for Lesion Recurrence
For both atypia and early cancer, follow-up monitoring after surgery
is important to detect whether atypia has recurred (as it frequently
does) or whether another primary cancer lesion has developed. Since a
cancerous lesion poses more of a health risk than atypia, follow-up
schedules for cancer are usually more rigorous.
The table below highlights a typical follow-up schedule for patients
whose lesions have been successfully removed. This timeline can be
varied depending on the specific clinical characteristics and needs of
an individual patient.
Follow-Up by Severity
Atypia
(Less Severe) |
Carcinoma in situ |
Early Cancer
(More Severe) |
Follow-up care is individualized based on:
- severity of atypia
- response to surgical excision
- patient and surgeon preference
- logistic and geographic limitations
|
Monthly follow-up similar to early cancer schedule |
- First year: every month
- Second year: every other month
- Third year: every third month
- Fourth year: every fourth month
- Fifth year and indefinitely: every 6-12 months
|
|