|
62 Possible Lessons on Recovering Your Voice
I.
Strong Reason for Hope
-
Voice Problems – More Distressing Than People Understand
Generally,
people can't imagine the hardships. Though there are more dangerous
medical conditions, losing your voice is a special category of hardship
– tiring, isolating, discouraging. Day-to-day life without voice is
much harder than people can imagine without suffering the problem
themselves.
If a website could extend sympathy, this one would.
-
The Largest Problem – Getting Stuck and Giving Up
Thousands
of people with voice problems have tried to find help, made little
progress and finally have given up. Because people can live with voice
problems, many do and sometimes for the whole of their lives – even
from childhood.
- The Largest Truth – Large Majority of Cases Treatable
Once
diagnosed, most voice problems can be treated with some measure of
success. Most cases can be improved and many effectively resolved.
-
Hardest Cases – Often Treatable
Many of the hardest cases, including patients with hardly any voice, can be treated. Voices can be recovered.
-
Longest Cases – Often Treatable
People suffering voice problems for 5, 10, 20, 30 years usually are treatable as well. Some improvement is highly likely.
-
Once Untreatable Cases – Increasingly Treatable
Medical
knowledge and technology in the field of voice care are advancing fast.
Many cases not treatable a decade past now can be addressed, improved,
even resolved.
-
Failed Surgeries – Often Correctable
Some
surgical procedures, by a bad turn of events, can create a voice
problem to begin with. Other surgeries, intended to address a voice
problem specifically, can produce complications – bringing the patient
no help or worsening the condition altogether. Even these categories of
surgical problems may be treatable a second or third time around. In
the right physician's hands, a prior "problem surgery" often can be
remedied.
-
Marginally Improved Cases – May Be Further Improved
A
very common phenomenon among voice patients is the problem of reaching
a "plateau." The original problem may have been improved in part but
the patient feels he has been "plateaued" at an unhappy level of voice,
with no further improvement likely. These cases, too, very often can be
improved with the right treatment.
-
"Giving Up," Not Incurable Condition, the More Common Problem
The
disappointing lesson is that difficult voice problems often require an
epic journey – too many doctor appointments, too many treatments, too
many blind alleys and failed approaches – before the right diagnosis is
found. A frequent problem is that the patient becomes defeated along
the way and largely gives up. For the large majority of cases, there
will be a successful treatment if he or she "stays the course" long
enough. Persistence turns out to matter here.
Some Honest Qualifications
- Often Improvement, Not Total Cure
To
say that the large majority of voice conditions can be treated is not
to say totally cured. A right expectation may be that some voices can
be recovered completely and others just improved – though typically
meaningfully. In all cases, continuing care and treatment may be
required.
-
Minority of Cases – No Fix at All
Though
they are the minority of cases – most highly uncommon – there are some
voice conditions for which the medical profession has made little
progress. The key here is much the same as for all voice problems – to
avoid giving up hope too soon. The patient should make sure the
diagnosis of untreatable condition is confirmed by a specialist likely
to be certain in that judgment.
In the case of "no fix at
all", the patient should check back with voice specialists at some
point because advances and improvements are continually being made in
the field.
-
Voice Problem as Part of Larger Condition
There
are occasions in which a voice problem is one of the first symptoms of
a much larger disease such as, cancer, stroke, multiple sclerosis (MS),
Lou Gehrig's disease, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), Parkinson's
disease, or myasthenia gravis. This too is highly uncommon but, where
diagnosed, the long-term prospects for the voice are as unhappy as the
disease itself. (For more information, see Voice Dysfunction in Neurological Disorders, Laryngeal Atypia and Early Cancer and Laryngeal Advanced Cancer.)
-
The Occasional Terminal Disease
The
overwhelming majority of voice problems involve no urgent,
degenerative, terminal disease. Chances are that the voice problem is
"just a voice problem" – limited, benign, treatable. Still, there are
forms of cancer that begin in, or move to, the throat, the larynx, the
vocal folds. Some of the more troubling symptoms are identified in the
chapters on cancer. These symptoms should be taken seriously and
examined immediately. (For more information, see Laryngeal Atypia and Early Cancer and Laryngeal Advanced Cancer.)
I.
Getting to Diagnosis
The Exact, Specific, Right Diagnosis
- Diagnosis More Complicated Than You Imagine
There
are 20 to 30 diagnoses that most frequently cause voice problems. As
each diagnosis may yield similar symptoms – hoarseness, loss of voice,
major fatigue when speaking – isolating the correct underlying cause is
difficult.
-
A Very Specific Diagnosis Essential to Treatment
There's
no surprise here: The 20 to 30 most frequent diagnoses require
different kinds of treatments. One patient with a hoarse voice may have
partial paralysis of the nerves to the vocal folds requiring implants
to push the vocal folds closer together if non-resolved. A second
patient, with almost an identical hoarse voice, may have acid reflux
affecting the vocal folds (without the typical heartburn) requiring
only a long dose of an anti-reflux drug.
Seventy, eighty,
ninety percent of the work and time spent getting better may take place
just in getting to the right diagnosis. This is a good investment of
time.
-
Wrong or Partial Diagnosis Highly Common
Some
large number of patients, maybe the vast majority who are "stuck" with
long-term voice problems, most likely have multiple voice problems or a
"missing link" to the cause of the voice problem. As a way of lowering
expectations at the beginning and preparing for a long, uphill journey,
these patients should expect one, two, or even three "working"
diagnoses that need to be sorted out before getting to the definitive
diagnosis or combination of diagnoses. This is common. This is okay.
The problem is summoning the energy to keep up the search.
-
Laryngitis as the "Catch All" Diagnosis
There
is a temptation among patients – and even some physicians – to diagnose
voice problems as laryngitis or chronic laryngitis. This may not be
helpful. Laryngitis means little more than a "hoarse voice"; it does
not explain the underlying cause of hoarseness.
A Voice Problem Beyond a Few Weeks Is Not Likely Viral Laryngitis
What the layman thinks of as "laryngitis" – losing your voice with a
cold or a flu – should not go on long. Viral laryngitis usually passes
within two to three weeks of the rest of the symptoms of the cold or
flu. If it doesn't, the problem is not likely viral laryngitis.
-
Avoiding Patient Fatigue
Understandably,
a patient may give up on the process after several doctor visits,
several failed treatments. The best counsel, I'm afraid, is still
"Don't give up." A right diagnosis is available and a good treatment
likely.
-
Avoiding Physician Fatigue
The
voice field in medicine is a (very, very) narrow specialty. It is not
possible for more general physicians, even ear, nose, and throat
specialists (ENTs or otolaryngologists), to know the dozens of
diagnoses for a bad voice. The problem to watch out for is the
physician – even well intended – effectively giving up. A diagnosis of
chronic laryngitis can be a clue to a physician's concern about not
finding a more specific diagnosis. The counsel is not to give up; you
may need to visit more physicians, physicians increasingly specialized
in the problems of the voice.
-
Exact, Right Diagnosis Virtually Always Possible – Almost Always
Physician
voice specialists in the country will admit that there are a minority
of cases that cannot be treated. Physician voice specialists also admit
that there may be differing medical opinions. That said, reaching the
right diagnosis is virtually almost possible. This is the single goal
for the first stage of the journey. It is a goal worthy enough.
The right diagnosis may be a combination. A patient's voice problem may be multifactorial, i.e.,
caused by different disorders present at the same time, each requiring
specific treatment for effective and lasting voice care.
III.
Need for a Specialist's Care?
The Problem for the Generalist Physician
- About 5,000 Different Medical Conditions
As
of this writing, there are about 5,000 medical conditions covered in
medical databases. No single physician, no matter the intelligence and
expertise and earnest compassion, can master even 10 percent of the
known medical field.
-
Serious Voice Problems: The Very Narrowest Specialty
While
everyone suffers some voice problem from time to time, truly serious,
long-term voice problems are relatively uncommon. Likely there are
about 50 physicians in the country who spend a third of their time
dedicated to patients with voice problems, although that cadre is
increasing in number and training.
-
The Pyramid of Increasing Voice Care Specialization
It
is possible to think of the various doctors treating voice problems as
organized in an inverted pyramid. The deeper down you penetrate, the
more specialized the doctor becomes in problems of the voice.
The Field of Doctors Treating Voice Problems in the United States, 2003
-
Not More Doctors, More Specialization
Inevitably,
the patient who is truly "stuck" with a long-term voice problem will
(and probably should) see a large number of doctors. The short cut, if
there is one, is not more doctors only, but also greater and greater
specialization. In the end, as with other medical specialties, the
toughest cases may best be diagnosed and treated by a subspecialist.
Voice disorders will require that very uncommon physician – the voice
specialist.
-
Beginning with a General Otolaryngologist
Laryngology,
the medical specialty focusing on voice care is a subspecialty of
otolaryngology. Most voice problems, beyond the simple cold and flu,
probably should be taken to an otolaryngologist. The overwhelming
majority of voice problems can be resolved there.
-
Moving from General Otolaryngologist to Physician Voice Specialist
As
with most medical specialties, there are several subspecialties within
the specialty of otolaryngology (ENT). These subspecialties focus on a
greater degree of expertise for the diagnosis and/or treatment of
particular ear/nose/throat disorders. One of these subspecialties,
laryngology, focuses on disorders of the larynx or voice box.
Voice disorders may best be treated by physician voice specialists whose clinical practice is focused on voice disorders. (For more information, see Voice Care Team.)
Diagnosis Within Three Visits or Three Weeks
A very happy fact about voice problems is that almost all can be
diagnosed, by a qualified physician voice specialist, virtually
immediately – sometimes on-site, sometimes after a separate test or
two, but almost always within three weeks or three visits. If diagnosis
is taking longer than that, it may be prudent to seek an appointment
with a dedicated physician voice specialist.
-
Embarrassment of Changing Doctors
There's
almost no adequate reassurance that can be given here. It's just
difficult for a patient to explain he wants to seek a second opinion.
Still, you should know this is very, very common. Further, if there is
any area where a general physician or even an otolaryngologist should
be forgiven for needing a further specialist called in, it is the
narrow terrain of serious voice problems. Sorry the advice here is not
more helpful.
IV.
Search for the Specific Doctor
Finding a Dedicated Voice Specialist
By
far, the larger number of voice problems can be well-tended by an
otolaryngologist. The conclusions that follow apply to those less
common circumstances when the patient feels "stuck" and in need of a
dedicated physician voice specialist.
-
No Easy Search
Finding
a true voice specialist in the United States is no easy matter. While
there are tests and review boards to qualify doctors as specialists in
some fields (cardiology, oncology, orthopedics and so forth), currently
there is no official qualification for specializing in the voice in
particular.
-
Measuring the Doctor's Focus – The "33% Test"
Though
the test is imperfect, you may wish to divide out that small number of
otolaryngologists who spend a third of their time seeing patients with
voice problems. This will yield a small field, almost certainly fewer
than 60 physicians, maybe as few as two to three dozen.
The 33% Test is no absolute standard, more a rough test for the average
patient to seek out the dedicated specialists. Surely, there are
otolaryngologists qualified for the most serious voice conditions,
though the majority of their practices are not patients' voice
disorders. There may be, as well, physicians more than 33 percent
dedicated to the voice who, nonetheless, are not the right doctor for a
specific voice problem.
-
The Larger Lesson – High Volume of Voice Patients
Research
has shown across many medical specialties that the quality of a
physician's care improves with the number of similar patients seen.
High-volume open heart surgeons, all things being equal, should yield
better heart surgery results. The patient "stuck" with a serious or
chronic voice problem may be well served finding those few doctors who
see the greatest number of vocal patients.
-
Twenty Hours of Doing Your Own Research
A
hard moment in seeking medical help is when, or if, the patient decides
to do his own research to find the right specialist. This work can be
aggressive – many telephone calls, lots of technical reading – but
likely will not require more than 20 hours of dedicated effort. Some
layman's tips for research – truly nothing more than that – are offered
below.
Finding a Voice Specialist
First "Leads" for the Patient's Own Research
Medical
Associations wherein some, most or all members are physician voice
specialists [listed in alphabetical order] – all have websites
-
Choir Directors – Musical Directors – Singing Teachers: Major Choirs, Operas, Schools
Across
the course of their singing careers, almost all professional – or
simply serious – singers will seek the medical care of a physician
specializing in the voice. Taking care of their own singers, most choir
directors, musical directors or creative directors of large choirs and
opera companies will know the names of physician voice specialists.
(The larger the choir or opera company, the better the chance the
musical director will know a voice specialist.) A few phone calls (or
e-mails) to such groups may start the research process.
-
Major University Hospitals
Some
university hospitals and academic medical centers have created
dedicated voice centers with one or more otolaryngologists focused on
voice care. The problem here is a little "hit or miss." All university
hospitals will have a physician to whom they refer voice problems. That
is not to say, however, that the designated physician truly will be a
voice specialist, dedicating some large portion of his practice to
voice problems. Some of the largest and most famous academic medical
centers in the country have no particular expertise in the voice.
Even
so, a round of phone calls to the larger university hospitals, asking
for "leads" to the nation's best-recognized voice specialists should
yield results. You may want to ask, in particular, the advice of the
chairman of the department of otolaryngology or the chief resident
(physician in training) in "ENT" – ear, nose, and throat.
There
are over 100 academic medical centers in the United States. Information
on each (including links to their respective websites) can be found on
the public website of the national society of academic medical centers
– the Association of American Medical Colleges.
Association of American Medical Colleges
2450 N Street, NW
Washington, DC 20037-1126
Phone: (202) 828-0400
Fax: (202) 828-1125
http://www.aamc.org/
-
This website offers a layman's strategy to finding a voice doctor in our "Resources" section. It can be found here.
-
The Likely Case: Be Prepared to Travel
The
scarcity of dedicated physician voice specialists there are in the
United States is an important factor that is difficult to overstress.
Some of the country's largest cities, with populations in the millions,
offer no doctor whose practice is largely dedicated to voice care. Most
voice conditions do not require such specialization. If, however, your
case does, the larger chance is that you will need to travel beyond
your own state or region.
Verifying a Specialist's Qualifications
- No Layman's Test for Quality
In
the end, the patient's ability to know the professional expertise of a
physician is limited, especially in as narrow and technical a specialty
as the voice. Most patients can't know. The same holds true even for
referring physicians.
-
Attributes of a Large Vocal Practice
That
a physician sees some large number of vocal patients is no guarantee of
quality or technical expertise. Still, in the absence of a better
measure, knowing whether a physician's practice – the doctor's time,
the staff's training, the medical equipment available – is largely
focused on vocal care may be helpful. Unquestionably, some number of
voice disorders require this principal focus.
Typical Attributes of Dedicated Voice Centers
- Physician voice specialist
|
- Staffed by otolaryngologists who specialize in voice disorders
|
- Multidisciplinary voice care team [on-site or available by easy referral]
|
- Speech-language pathologist
- Voice therapist
- Nurse
- Medical and surgical sub-specialists
|
- Specialized voice testing [on-site or available by easy referral]
|
- Laryngoscopy:
- Rigid or telescopic laryngoscopy
- Flexible or fiber optic laryngoscopy
- Videostroboscopy
- Laryngeal electromyography
- Voice function testing
- Double-probe pH monitoring
|
- Specialized surgical procedures for voice disorders
|
- Phonomicrosurgery
- Laryngeal framework surgery
- Neural re-innervation
|
- Physicians whose research has been published in peer-reviewed publications
|
- Not a requirement, but a plus as with all medical specialties
|
(For more information, see Overview of Voice Care Professionals, Laryngoscopy/Stroboscopy, Phonomicrosurgery,
Reflux Laryngitis chapter section on pH monitoring.) |
-
Final Caution: Subspecialization Even Among Specialists
There
is trouble enough for many patients simply finding a physician who
specializes in voice conditions. The further problem, all but too much
to handle, is that all physician voice specialists do not claim
expertise in all voice conditions. There are deep spikes of
subspecialization within the subspecialty – practices focused on one or
more of the following: vocal fold cancer, vocal fold paresis/paralysis,
reflux laryngitis, recurrent respiratory papillomatosis (RRP),
laryngeal reconstruction-rehabilitation, spasmodic dysphonia and so
forth.
Once the patient has a specific diagnosis, it is
always a worthy question to ask, "Doctor, if your family member had
this condition, who would you suggest as the one or two or three best
doctors in the country to handle the treatment?"
V.
Various Medical Complexities
- Visiting a Physician Immediately
While
it is true that most voice conditions do not involve more serious
underlying problems, there are some symptoms worthy of a physician's
immediate attention. A partial list of red flag symptoms is offered
below.
Red Flag Symptoms – Warranting Immediate Attention
- Difficulty breathing – especially breathing in
- Coughing up blood
- Episodes of choking on food and liquid – aspirating, food getting stuck, food and liquid going down the wrong way
- Hoarseness and ear pain
- Gradual
deterioration of the voice – greater and greater hoarseness or vocal
fatigue setting in across weeks or months (with or without accompanying
pain)
The Problem of Simultaneous Voice Conditions
- When No One Diagnosis Is Enough
There
is a growing view among some of the nation's most-respected physician
voice specialists that most "stubborn and persistent" voice conditions
involve more than one underlying problem or diagnosis. In this view,
it's as if a single problem often may not be enough to reduce the
larynx to chronic fatigue, hoarseness or significant trouble speaking.
Rather, it's as if the voice struggles along at acceptable levels until
the accumulation of voice problems puts the larynx "over the edge."
Only then does the patient seek treatment.
-
The Special Difficulty in Diagnosis
Spotting
multiple, simultaneous voice conditions is a highly sophisticated art,
generally requiring the attention of a dedicated physician voice
specialist. The practical problem for the patient and physician is that
once a first problem has been identified, the natural temptation is to
assume that explains the whole of the problem. The result often may be
too simple a diagnosis, too simple a treatment, and some confusion when
the problem does not resolve.
-
Needing to Treat Each Problem Separately
When
multiple and simultaneous voice problems are at work, it may be
necessary to treat each problem separately to recover the patient's
voice.
-
Common Clusters of Problems
The
experience of some of the busiest voice practices suggests there are
some common clusters of voice problems, separate diagnoses that – for
whatever reason – often are found together in chronic vocal conditions.
Some of the more common clusters are listed below.
Common Clusters of Voice Problems
- High-demand voice user
- Vocal fold scarring
- Vocal fold nodules, polyps or cysts
Resulting symptoms: hoarseness, vocal fatigue, effortful phonation |
- Reflux laryngitis
- Vocal fold granuloma
Resulting symptoms: hoarseness, frequent throat clearing, vocal fatigue, pain on speaking |
- Vocal fold paralysis
- Muscle tension dysphonia
Resulting symptoms: hoarseness, breathiness, effortful speaking, vocal fatigue |
- Spasmodic dysphonia
- Anxiety or stressful situation
- Muscle tension dysphonia
Resulting symptoms: strained strangled breaks in voice or breathy breaks in voice |
- Smoking history
- Vocal fold cancer
Resulting symptoms (any combination): hoarseness, past or present smoker, pain to ear, difficulty breathing |
- History of endotracheal intubation
- Joint mobility problems
- Vocal fold scarring
- Paralysis or paresis
- Vocal fold granuloma
Resulting symptoms: non-resolved hoarseness after intubation, pain on speaking |
- Excess voice use
- Vocal fold hemorrhage
Resulting symptoms: acute severe voice loss following screaming/shouting (voice abuse) or performance or demanding voice use |
- Psychogenic aphonia
- Physical and/or sexual abuse
Resulting
symptoms: "tip of the iceberg"; physician voice specialists have
observed cases of complete loss of voice as presenting symptom of
underlying abuse |
- Cancer of the Vocal Folds and Larynx Reasonably Uncommon
Less
than three to five percent of voice conditions are caused by vocal fold
pre-cancerous lesions and cancer. The most common kind of vocal fold
cancer is the squamous cell carcinoma. More importantly, the most
common risk factor for vocal fold cancer is smoking – past or current.
Precancerous
lesions on the vocal folds or vocal fold atypia are more common. These
lesions are thought to precede vocal fold cancer.
-
Possible Cancer Symptoms
Though cancer can present in many ways, some of the more common clusters of symptoms for vocal cancer are:
- Persistent hoarseness especially in a smoker or past smoker
- Hoarseness + pain to the ear
- Worsening hoarseness
- Difficult or noisy breathing
-
Cancer Need Not Involve Pain
Laryngeal and vocal fold cancer may or may not involve pain. Lack of pain is not an assurance of no cancer.
-
Diagnosing Vocal Fold or Laryngeal Cancer
Using
a scope placed down the throat, an otolaryngologist or voice specialist
may be able to see visible signs of cancer including hemorrhagic
lesions, growths protruding outwards, and growths immobilizing part of
the vocal folds. To confirm a cancer diagnosis, the physician must do a
biopsy, removing a portion or all of the growth for laboratory
pathology testing.
-
Problem with Single Biopsies
Increasingly,
physicians are of the opinion that a single biopsy of a growth may not
be enough to locate cancer within the growth – one sample may have
"missed" the cancer. The better practice may be removal of the whole
growth including a margin or edge of normal tissue.
-
Problem with a Simple "Yes" or "No"
Not
surprisingly, diagnosis may not be as simple as "cancer" or "no
cancer." Areas of the larynx and vocal folds can have premalignant
(precancerous) lesions. These early changes in the health of the tissue
need to be addressed aggressively as well. (For more information, see Laryngeal Atypia and Early Cancer.)
-
Most Early Cancer Treatable with Voice Preservation
Most
early cancers of the larynx and vocal folds can be treated with
preservation of the voice. Vocal fold cancer treatment and voice
preservation are no longer incompatible. (For more information, see Laryngeal Atypia and Early Cancer.)
-
Avoiding Total Removal of the Larynx
The
traditional and conservative approach to more serious cases of
laryngeal cancer has been to remove the larynx – leaving the patient
without any natural voice, wholly dependent on a mechanical voice box.
While still necessary in some cases, this is no longer the
state-of-the-art practice at some of the largest voice centers.
In
many cases, larynx cancer surgeons now are able to preserve the voice
box while successfully removing all of the cancerous growth. The result
typically can be to leave the patient with a usable voice without the
need for a device in cases which otherwise might have left the patient
with no voice at all.
A physician's recommendation to have the larynx removed (a total
laryngectomy) should trigger the search for a second opinion.
The Problem of Laryngitis
- A Deeply Unhelpful Diagnosi
Patients commonly diagnose their own hoarse voices as laryngitis. Similarly, physicians may offer a diagnosis of laryngitis.
The
problem is that laryngitis simply means "inflammation of the larynx or
voice box" manifesting itself as hoarseness. It does not uncover the
underlying reason for the laryngitis. The work doesn't begin until the
patient and physician search for the root cause of the "laryngitis."
-
Laryngitis With a Cold or Flu
The
most common form of hoarseness is caused by a viral infection resulting
in the common cold or flu. While common, this form of laryngitis should
not last long. The hoarseness almost always clears up within two to
three weeks after the rest of the cold or flu symptoms are gone. If
hoarseness continues long after the cold or flu, likely there is some
problem other than the typical flu-related laryngitis, or complications
may have occurred that require medical attention. This is especially
true for smokers.
A Voice Problem Beyond a Few Weeks Is Not Likely Viral Laryngitis
What the layman thinks of as "laryngitis" – losing your voice with a
cold or the flu – should not go on long. Cold- or flu-related
laryngitis usually passes within two to three weeks of the rest of the
symptoms of the cold or flu. If it doesn't, there may be complications
or another voice disorder that was worsened by the bout of the flu.
Lingering horseness should not simply be ignored as something that will
someday go away.
-
Other Causes of Laryngitis
Beyond the cold or flu, there are numerous causes for hoarseness. Some of the more common causes are cited below.
Common Causes of Hoarseness
- Reflux laryngitis
- Vocal fold scar
- Damage to the vocal folds from excess talking or shouting – vocal fold hemorrhage
- Vocal fold paresis
- Vocal fold lesions
-
Side Problem of Cold or Flu – Vocal Fold Paresis/Paralysis
Though
the phenomenon is uncommon, a common cold or flu can leave the nerves
serving the vocal muscles partially paralyzed (paresis). The thinking
here is that, as with the herpes virus, the virus may affect the nerve
and weaken it or deaden it altogether. The result is one or both vocal
folds becoming weak or sluggish.
Improvement in voice function can be achieved even if one has vocal fold paralysis (total paralysis). (For more information, see Vocal Fold Paresis / Paralysis and Laryngeal Electromyography [LEMG].)
The Problem of Voice Rest
- Not Generally the Right Treatmen
Although
voice rest is indicated in specific treatment situations, its role in
treatment is usually only a part of the treatment plan. Though often
prescribed, voice rest is not definitive treatment for most causes of
voice disorder. Voice rest simply allows time for the vocal folds to
recover on their own – from fatigue or swelling or irritation. The root
cause of the voice disorder needs to be identified and specific
treatment or treatments prescribed.
| Voice Rest Usually Appropriate |
Voice Rest Usually Not Helpful
Current best practice: needs medical attention for voice problem |
Recovering from pushing the voice too long, too hard |
Persistent hoarseness that was unresponsive to a three-week course of voice rest |
Recovering from vocal fold surgery |
Worsening hoarseness |
Voice fatigue from overuse |
Hoarseness + difficulty breathing in or swallowing |
Recovering from vocal fold hemorrhage |
Hoarseness lasting longer than three weeks, especially in smokers |
-
Limit of Three Weeks Vocal Rest – Usually
As
a practical matter, very few conditions require voice rest beyond two
to three weeks. If the patient's voice remains fragile thereafter, some
other cause should be examined and some other treatment should be
pursued.
One exception is vocal fold hemorrhage – wherein
voice rest may be prescribed for a longer period in some cases. The
distinction here is that a definite diagnosis has been made, and a
physician voice specialist is following the patient's progress.
-
Months of Voice Rest a Red Flag
Red Flag
A
patient advised to continue voice rest after two to three months likely
should seek a second opinion from a physician voice specialist. Likely,
the patient is suffering some problem for which rest is no complete
answer.
Most Common Diagnoses for Patients Truly "Stuck"
For patients
truly stuck with chronic voice problems, perhaps as many as 80% of the
cases can be explained by one or a combination of five diagnoses.
- Vocal fold scarring
- Reflux laryngitis
|